Written by: Hailey Wegner, SLU Dietetic Intern
When the word “dietitian” slips into conversation with any
friend or passerby – I often know what is going to come next... a question
regarding nutritional intake that this person wants to know about.
Friends: “What’s with this
keto diet... Anyway?”
Stranger at the grocery
store: “So...should I be eating more super foods?”
But when I am among young adults... there is one question
that almost always comes up.
Everyone: “Do I really have to cut out alcohol?”
This question especially comes up when the young adult wishes
to see physique changes. This is especially, especially true when the young adult is a competitive athlete...
and especially, especially, especially
true when the young adult is a competitive collegiate athlete.
_______________________
There is no question that drinking alcohol is written into
the culture of almost every college attendee. First year students of
traditional college often drink irresponsibly, and believe drinking to be integral
to the college experience with over 40% of college students endorse
heavy episodic or “binge” drinking (generally defined as 5 + drinks in one
sitting for men and 4 + drinks in one sitting for women)(1, 2).
This is not untrue for athletes. While some may believe that
the collegiate athlete is at a lower risk of engaging in binge drinking due to
scheduling constraints or the physical demand of peak performance; studies show
that students involved in sports have a higher
tendency to drink/get drunk/binge on alcohol more often than those students
with no involvement in sports(3).
So what DO I tell athletes when the question of: “so what about alcohol...” comes up?
_______________________
Me: “I’m glad you asked...
because it indicates that you care about your body performing the BEST that it
can...”
Depending on the circumstances that apply to the athlete in
front of me... I can choose from the LARGE array of evidence that shows the
detrimental effects of alcohol on athletic performance.
Me: “Alcohol consumption
disrupts our metabolism of nutrients... so your body and performance will
suffer.”
And its true! Research has shown that: Alcohol consumption has been shown to inhibit liver glucose
output during exercise; which can cause low blood sugar while exercising, and
alcohol will decrease muscle glucose uptake – so tissues cannot get the fuel
that they need. It also suppresses the breakdown of fatty acids—and is
therefore regarded as a risk factor for weight gain (5) . Alcohol
consumption prevents your body from absorbing important nutrients like thiamin,
vitamin B12, folic acid and zinc(4). (These nutrients help in the formation of new cells, boost
your immune system, and aid in the metabolism of proteins and fats).
Me: “Most importantly to
athletes, though, is that large amounts of alcohol can shut off muscle repair,
growth, and even has been shown to produce muscle wasting.” (7)
Which is ALSO true. AND... Athletes tend to consume the most alcohol in the 1-2 hours
after exercise, which is the timeframe that is the most critical for optimal
nutrient uptake. (6)
Me: “Not
surprisingly then... Athletes who drink alcohol at least
once per week have an elevated risk of injury as compared to athletes who do
not drink”
This is for a variety of
reasons... Alcohol is shown to increase fatigue during high-intensity exercise, (6)
which can lead to poor concentration and sloppy performance. Alcohol increases production of anti-inflammatory
molecules; and inflammation is a key part of the muscle repair process, and alcohol
consumption induces dehydration and loss of blood flow to active tissue. (6)
Me: “There are even some
detriments that most people wouldn’t think about... such as impaired
temperature regulation, depressed immune functioning, low testosterone
production, and decreased quality and duration of sleep.” (10, 6)
I am
sure we can all imagine how those could negatively impact performance.
Me:
“And I know you think you can hang... but even
mild hangover symptoms have direct impact on performance; such as: headache,
nausea, hypersensitivity to light or sound, diarrhea, fatigue,
dehydration, and body aches” (4)
Athlete: “Okay... so I will avoid
alcohol in-season... but it’ll be fine in off season.. right?
Me: “Well... actually, no. Studies
have shown “chronic” detrimental effects of alcohol can accumulate in as little
as as 6-weeks.”
Some well-researched chronic detriments include increased whole-body protein breakdown and long-term compromises to the immune system... which makes
an athlete more susceptible to career-delaying illnesses (6, 8)
Me: “But... Don’t worry! Everything
in moderation, including moderation... there is evidence that low doses of
alcohol can be safely consumed without an impact on performance”
That’s right! As long as the athlete is of legal drinking
age, low-to moderate doses of alcohol have been shown to have no effect on
certain subsets of athletic performance.
Studies show that low
doses of alcohol are unlikely to be detrimental to repletion of glycogen,
rehydration and muscle injury and have
little to no effect on muscle protein balance or muscle growth (11)
Notably, low doses of alcohol would be less than 1-2 drinks
per day for men, and less than ½-1 drink per day for women; and that “stacking”
these drinking events to 1-2 days per week is still considered binge drinking. (12) These
drinks would be measured using a “1 drink” equivalent of 5 oz of wine, 12 oz of
beer, or 1 shot (1.5 oz) of liquor (13) .
_______________________
All in all, the evidence AGAINST consuming alcohol while
participating in athletics is overwhelming. However, much like a
human-relationship to food, the human-relationship to alcohol can be seen
written into many aspects of collegiate culture. My overarching recommendation
for athletes always encompasses these two ideas.
Me: “It is best to avoid any
alcohol consumption to ensure top-notch athletic performance. But for athletes who choose to drink, you should become fiercely
aware with the AMOUNTS that are shown to cause no affect... drinking to achieve
social acceptance should not be a priority over your physical performance in
your sport, especially since there IS an amount of alcohol that is considered
safe to consume. With this in mind, avoid alcohol 48 hours prior to any
athletic event and rehydrate/ consume food BEFORE celebratory
drinking to slow alcohol absorption.”
Love,
Your Sports Dietitian
References:
1) Crawford, L. A., Novak, K. B., & Jayasekare, R. R.
(2019). Volunteerism, Alcohol Beliefs,
and First-Year College Students’ Drinking Behaviors: Implications for Prevention. The Journal of Primary Prevention,
40(4), 429-448. doi:10.1007/s10935-019-00558-z
2)
D.A. Dawson, B.F. Grant, F.S. Stinson, P.S. Chou,
Another look at heavy episodic drinking and alcohol use disorders among
college and noncollege youth, Journal
of Studies on Alcohol, 65 (2004), pp. 477-488
3) Ford JA. Alcohol use
among college students: a comparison of athletes and nonathletes. Subst Use Misuse. 2007;42(9):1367–77.
4) Alcohol and Athletic Performance. (n.d.). Retrieved from https://alcohol.stanford.edu/alcohol-drug-info/staying-safe/alcohol-and- athletic-performance
5) Suter, P., Schutz, Y. The
effect of exercise, alcohol or both combined on health and physical performance. Int J Obes 32, S48–S52 (2008). https://doi.org/10.1038/ijo.2008.206
6) Barnes MJ. Alcohol: impact
on sports performance and recovery in male athletes. Sports Med. 2014 Jul;44(7):909-19. doi: 10.1007/s40279-014-0192-8.
PMID: 24748461)
7) Steiner JL, Lang CH. Dysregulation of skeletal muscle protein
metabolism by alcohol. Am J
Physiol Endocrinol Metab. 2015 May 1;308(9):E699-712. doi: 10.1152/ajpendo.00006.2015. Epub 2015 Mar 10.
PMID: 25759394; PMCID: PMC4420901.
8) Hong-Brown LQ, Frost
RA, Lang CH. Alcohol impairs protein synthesis and degradation in cultured skeletal muscle cells. Alcohol Clin Exp Res.
2001;25(9):1373–82.
9) Cameron C. et al, Sport-related
achievement motivation and alcohol
outcomes: An athlete-specific risk
factor among intercollegiate athletes,
Addictive Behaviors, Volume 38,
Issue 12, 2013, Pages 2930-2936, ISSN
0306-4603,
10) Yoda T, et al,. Effects
of alcohol on thermoregulation during mild heat exposure in humans. Alcohol. 2005 Jul;36(3):195-200.
doi: 10.1016/j.alcohol.2005.09.002.
PMID: 16377461.
11) Kimball, S. R., & Lang, C.
H. (2018). Mechanisms Underlying Muscle Protein Imbalance Induced by Alcohol. Annual review of nutrition, 38, 197–217. https://doi.org/10.1146/annurev-nutr-071816-064642)
12) Maraldi, C., et al,. (2009). Moderate Alcohol Intake and
Risk of Functional Decline: The Health,
Aging, and Body Composition Study. Journal of the American Geriatrics Society, 57(10), 1767-1775.
doi:10.1111/j.1532- 5415.2009.02479.x
13) National Institute on Alcohol
Abuse and Alcoholism. (NIH Publication No. 07- 3769).Helping patients who drink too much: a
clinician’s guide (updated) 2007